Confusion reigns over Sebi margin rule 1.0: There’s Model 2.Zero too


NEW DELHI: At the same time as confusion reigns over the introduction of margin rules within the cash segment from September 1 as brokers declare unpreparedness at their degree and that of the depositories, there may be one other deadline looming for the trade for Margin Norm 2.0. That has to do with adjustments in margin buying and selling in derivatives, the phase that generates largest volumes on Dalal Street .

The tweaks in margin rule for by-product buying and selling will come into pressure from December 1. Beneath these guidelines, merchants will likely be compelled to progressively go in the direction of maintaining full margin based mostly on peak positions throughout a day.

Market regulator Sebi says the choice was taken to scale back threat in monetary markets, and curb the apply of extreme leverage. The adjustments will make it troublesome to take a big place, if one doesn’t have sufficient money within the trading account.

ETMarkets did the legwork to try to perceive the problems at hand, and extra importantly, how the upcoming adjustments may have an effect on traders somehow. The solutions we discovered have been based mostly largely on our discussions with Venu Madhav, Chief of Operations at Zerodha. The primary half handled the whats and whys and the second on penalty provisions. Within the third and remaining half, we try to know how the adjustments within the by-product phase are going to have an effect on merchants and brokers. Learn on…

How does margin buying and selling work in futures (by-product) markets?

To know this, let’s take the instance of Nifty futures. As of at the moment, to purchase or promote one lot of Nifty futures, you want round Rs 1.5 lakh in your buying and selling account. That is known as exchange-mandated margin required to take a place (taking a place means both shopping for or promoting).

Now, suppose your buying and selling account steadiness is simply Rs 20,000. Theoretically, you shouldn’t have the ability to take any place in Nifty futures. In apply, many brokers mean you can take positions on the situation that you’d sq. off on the finish of the day.

How do brokers enable that?

They both use funds obtainable in different shoppers’ accounts to make up for the shortfall, or take loans. In your case, your shortfall of Rs 1.three lakh (Rs 1,50,000-Rs 20,000) is offered by your dealer. On the finish of the day, the place is squared off. And, after adjusting for beneficial properties or loss, the dealer will return your cash to you.

Presently, margin reporting is completed on the finish of the day. However since you don’t have any place on the finish of the day, the margin required is zero. It is a win-win recreation for each brokers and merchants, however it creates dangers for the monetary system.

“No matter you purchase intraday, it isn’t checked. Suppose, you had taken a place of Rs 100 crore within the morning, however your place is squared off on the finish of the day, no margin is required. This was recognized as a threat, as brokers at the moment give loopy quantities in margins. This places different clients’ cash in danger,” stated Venu Madhav, Chief of Operations at Zerodha.

What’s the change in rule proposed?

What Sebi is altering is, aside from the end-of-the-day margin examine, there can even be a peak margin reporting, that’s, what’s the highest open place of the consumer in a given day. For instance, in a day when you had purchased 5 a lot of Nifty futures at 11 am and 5 extra at 12 midday earlier than squaring off every part at three pm, it will likely be checked when you had Rs 15 lakh (peak margin required for the place) in your account or not. Brokers will likely be penalised if there may be any shortfall. The rule will likely be carried out from Dec 1. That is to discourage the apply of over-leveraging, that creates dangers within the monetary market, stated Madhav.

So, would I must have the total quantity in my account to take a place from Dec 1?

Sure, and no. Ideally, it is best to, however it could additionally rely in your dealer. Sebi is implementing the margin requirement in a phased method, in order that market contributors get used to the rule. From Dec 1, a dealer must have 25 per cent of peak margin in her account. The quantum will likely be 50 per cent from March 1, 75 per cent within the subsequent three months and 100 per cent from September 1, 2021.

“Ideally, brokers need to do 100 per cent assortment. Sebi is saying you report simply 25 per cent from Dec 1. This time has been given to brokers to streamline their techniques and make it correct sufficient in a yr,” stated Madhav.



Leave a Reply